3. Chris Carpenter
Credit: Getty Images
A fan favorite and post-season hero, Carpenter is currently edging Wainwright at 1,085 strikeouts in his career. Since 2004 Carpenter has been working the mound in St. Louis, and in that time he’s won a Cy Young, been an All-Star three times and won two World Series rings. While still active, he is battling an injury and unlikely to return to the game. Were he to retire, he will have won 95 games for team.