Palace takes legal route as topless photos spread

Palace takes legal route as topless photos spread

Credit: KENZO TRIBOUILLARD/AFP/GettyImages

A man holds a copy of the celebrity magazine Closer, which published topless pictures of Prince William's wife Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, taken while the pair were on holiday in France on September 5, in a street of Paris on September 14, 2012. Announcing a world exclusive, Closer magazine invited readers on its website to pick up he new edition to enjoy 'the photos that the world can't wait to see; the Duchess of Cambridge topless on a guesthouse terrace'. AFP PHOTO / KENZO TRIBOUILLARD (Photo credit should read KENZO TRIBOUILLARD/AFP/GettyImages)

Print
Email
|

by GREGORY KATZ and LORI HINNANT

Associated Press

Posted on September 17, 2012 at 11:56 AM

Updated Monday, Sep 17 at 12:21 PM

(CBS News) Lawyers for Prince William and his wife, Catherine, will be in a Paris court later Monday. They plan to make a criminal complaint against the photographer who took topless pictures of her.

 

But there’s an argument about whether the royals taking legal action will limit the photos or just make them more intriguing.

One place where all the fuss about a royal’s topless photos may seem spectacularly out of place is where William and Catherine, the former Kate Middleton, happened to be Monday - the South Pacific paradise of the Solomon Islands - where the unclothed human form is no big deal.

The remote islands may seem like another world to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge. Back in their real world, though, their lawyers were busy taking action in the courts in France.

A Paris celebrity gossip magazine was first to publish pictures of the frolicking, half-naked couple enjoying what they thought was a private holiday at the queen’s nephew’s house. The royal lawyers are making a formal criminal complaint against the photographer who took the pictures and against the magazine.

That didn’t stop another European publication - this time in Italy - from putting out a special issue containing a 26-page photo spread of the couple. An Irish newspaper has printed them, as well. Outside of Britain, the royals are treated with less reverence.

Neil Wallis, a newspaper editor, told CBS News, “It is seen as, if you like, another celebrity complaining about their privacy. How ever much as I sympathize with Kate, it’s not going to close the door. The horse has bolted.”

Palace lawyers are said to be considering what to do as the photos show up more and more places. Should they launch suits everywhere or make an example of the French? Because the more they talk about the photos, the more everybody else does, too.

Wallis said, “They are literally financially becoming more valuable, the pictures you must not see, the pictures they tried to ban, that literally is music to the (paparazzo’s) ears.”

The problem for William and Kate is that the penalties under French law for invasion of privacy are piddling compared to the circulation boost for the magazine—about $45,000, although there is provision for jailing the editor for a year. Still, the couple are said to be livid as the photos continue to be published. They’re going to have to make a decision whether to continue the legal pressure - and so the concentration on the photos - or move on.

 

Print
Email
|